Klenk Law

Correctly Timing Orphans Court Discovery

Posted on Mon Jun 30, 2014, on Estate Litigation

From our “Ask a Question” Mailbag: I am a beneficiary to a Trust. How do I know the Trustee is doing what she is supposed to when she files the Accounting? Is there a procedure for Orphans Court Discovery?

Most Recently Updated on July 1, 2018

Estate Litigation Lawyer Discusses Orphans Court Discovery

Orphans Court Discovery, a Primer.

Discovery is at times the answer if the Trustee is not cooperating in providing pertinent information. Whenever a fiduciary files an Orphans’ Court Accounting, whether the filing is by an Agent under a Power of Attorney, a Trustee of a Trust or the Executor of an Estate, a person interested in that accounting has a handicap. The person filing the accounting has all the information; the beneficiary has only what the fiduciary has given them.

Do I have a right to object to an Accounting if I believe it is wrong?

Interested persons do have a right to object to an accounting, but if, for example, the beneficiary does not have access to the bank statements, how exactly does the beneficiary know if the charges reflected on the accounting are accurate?

Typically, the fiduciary will provide all this information voluntarily to the beneficiary’s estate litigation attorney, but sometimes they do not.

How does the beneficiary obtain the records and information they need to accurately object to the accounting?

I find that when explaining legal matters, following the actual facts of an actual case can help understand how the law works. Though I could give you a general outline of the Orphan’s Court Rules on discovery I think you will find it easier to understand if the rules are applied to a set of real facts.

In this example, I will use the case, Robinson Estate, decided upon by the Orphans’ Court Division of the Court of Common Pleas of Monroe County.

The issue before the court was whether or not to grant the Petition to Compel Discovery Answers.

Factual Background:

  • BR died. During his lifetime, RG served as his Agent under a Power of Attorney.
  • RR filed BR’s will and began serving as Executor of the estate of BR.
  • RR filed a Petition to force RG to Account, and to distribute real property claimed to be part of the probate estate.
  • RG filed an accounting with the Monroe County Orphans’ Court.
  • A year passed without anyone filing objections to RG’s accounting.
  • RR reviewed the accounting, but before filing objections he wanted to do discovery in order to focus his objections.
  • He sent to RG a set of Interrogatories and Request for Documents.
  • RG would not respond to the interrogatories.
  • BR, filed the Petition to Compel Discovery Answers, hoping the judge would allow discovery. BR is, therefore, the “petitioner”, RG is the “respondent”.

Respondent’s Legal Arguments:

RG argued that discovery is not appropriate at this point in the accounting process because there have not been any objections to his accounting filed. If there is not yet a dispute, how can the court order him to turn over documents? RR filed a petition to account and RG filed an account. RG reasons that he satisfied everything that RR had requested, so until RR objects to his accounting, there is no dispute, so no discovery is allowed under the Orphans’ Court Rules.

How the Judge Reasoned:

  • First, the judge noted that RR’s petition was not limited to requesting that RG account, it also requested the return of certain real property to the probate estate.
  • The judge then explained the applicable procedural rules:
  • The Orphans’ Court is able to prescribe the practice relating to discovery on matters before it.
  • Rule 3.6 of the Supreme Court Orphans’ Court Rules also permits the local Orphans’ Court to prescribe the discovery practice, and unless otherwise prescribed by local rule, discovery shall conform to the civil division practice.
  • In Monroe County, there is no local Orphans’ Court Rule specific to discovery (therefore, Rule 3.6 says the court should conform to the civil division practice).
  • The judge then found that it is common practice to allow pre-complaint discovery in certain situations in the Civil Court.

How the Judge Ruled:

  • After finding that pre-complaint discovery is comparative to pre-objection discovery, the judge reasoned that it would be helpful to the petitioner to have discovery prior to filing objections to the accounting. Potentially, the discovery would help “clarify and narrow the scope of the matters to be objected to by him.”
  • The Petition to Compel Discovery Answers was Granted, and GR was ordered to answer RR’s First set of Interrogatories and Request for Documents.

Further Estate Litigation Questions?

Discovery is only one of many Estate Litigation issues our firm addresses. Consequently, if you want to learn more, please read my more detailed article, Trust and Estate Litigation All You Need to Know.

In Conclusion: 

I hope that this article was helpful in explaining Discovery. Further, I included links to even more detailed information on my website. Therefore, please contact me and let me know how I did. Certainly, your comments and questions are welcome!

Let our Litigation Lawyers help walk you through what can be a confusing process. To begin with, call to speak to one of our experienced Litigation Attorneys.  By all means, our lawyers are ready to answer your questions. In fact, feel free to contact our office for a free consultation. Ultimately our goal is to put our 25 years of estate litigation experience to work for you.

Wills, Trusts, Probate, and Estate Litigation It’s All We Do!

Will Contest Lawyer addresses Orphans Court Discovery,

Will Contest Lawyer, Glen Ridenour.

Will Contest Attorney, Glen Ridenour.

Author, Peter Klenk, Esq.

Tags:

Breach of Fiduciary Duty, Estate Litigation, Estate Litigation Attorney, Estate Litigation Lawyer, Fiduciary Duty, Litigation, Pennsylvania

What Our clients are saying

Stars

Peter provided outstanding advice and preparation of a will and trusts.

Stars

Peter was excellent. He explained everything very clearly and is super friendly. My wife and I originally tried using a lawyer through group legal coverage, but unfortunately the old adage - "you get what you pay for" - applied to the other lawyer, and we decided to go with a real professional.

Stars

When it came down to picking the right attorney to handle my affairs, I knew right away it was this firm. From speaking to their secretary to speaking to Peter I knew I was making the right decision. After only a few mins Peter knew right away what I was looking for and handled all my questions professionally and even gave me great feedback that put my mind at ease. All that without even giving a single penny! So of course I hired him! So far so good...

Stars

AWESOME LAWYER! Peter Klenk is an exceptional attorney and a very nice person! Today I spoke with Peter about estate planning and was impressed with by his professionalism, cordiality, and attention to detail. I highly recommend Klenk Law for probates, wills, trusts, and other issues germane to estate planning!

Stars

Great friendly staff

Stars

Tremendous firm with bright, kind and tenacious people. Great representation for our family.

Stars

I'm totally satisfied with Klenk Law. Peter has a great legal mind with the personality of the guy next door.

Stars

Everything about my experience was a 10+! Peter and his staff made what I thought would be a difficult process easy and understandable. Every detail was handled correctly. No other firm could possibly do better than Klenk Law!

Stars

Peter and his staff are very responsive and always willing to help my clients and in a cost efficient manner.

Stars

Like another reviewer, I contacted Peter through his website using the free consultation link, for a question regarding PA inheritance taxes. The question was quite technical and difficult to explain, and the answer was nowhere to be found on the web. Peter grasped precisely what I was asking, and provided a clear, helpful response (with a touch of humor) the very next day.

Stars

Answered my question quickly and referred me to a colleague that could handle my problem

Stars

Mr. Klenk, quickly understood the circumstances presented and provided clear and concise advice. This advice provided me with the information I required to progress the case to my advantage.

Stars

Peter is excellent. I had a very complicated situation with my parents' estate planning and potential Medicaid needs. Peter was very knowledgeable in estate planning matters, able to define the best solution for the situation. Additionally, he was congenial and able to communicate effectively to my senior citizen parents the benefits of estate planning. He earned my trust, and more importantly, my parents' trust in a 45 mins consultation period. Highly recommend Peter. He is very easy to work with.

Stars

Peter recently gave a presentation about Wills & Trusts at my employer, and it was fantastic! He was extremely knowledgeable and provided valuable information to the group. People were very engaged and asked several questions, all of which Peter thoroughly answered. Personally, my husband and I have selected Peter to help us with our estate planning, and he has been very helpful in providing us with all of the information we need to provide a secure future for our family. Thank you, Peter!

Stars

Peter provided outstanding advice and preparation of a will and trusts.

Stars

Peter explained things in a way that was easy to understand. Everything was done in the time frame he said it. Could not have been better!

Stars

You & your staff are the best thank you for everything.

Stars

Peter and his staff handled all of our needs in a very professional and timely matter.

Stars

Peter Klenk made a complex subject understandable and allowed us to move forward with our estate planning. He was patient with our questions and creative in the solutions he proposed.

Stars

Peter explained a complex subject very clearly, helped us to decide the best approach to managing our estate and then made it very easy for us to execute the required documents. He will be a valuable resource for years to come and clearly has a great understanding of estate law that will lead to innovative solutions for us. I would unhesitatingly recommend him for estate planning.

Stars

Fantastic customer service. Very personable and most importantly they provide great explanations of what is required based on your individual needs. Highly recommend Klenk Law for anyone that needs to create a will and estate documents.

Stars

Always professional and very responsive. Everyone on the staff that I have worked with. I look forward to continuing our relationship.

Stars

Surprisingly easy

Stars

Affable...yet surprisingly cerebral estate planning atty. High marks all the way around.

Stars

Peter and his associates made things easy for us.

Let us put our expertise to work for you.

Free consultation within 24 hours.